The ultimate question is, do
animals have rights? If so, what kind of rights and who will protect them?
There is a lot of negligence with animals, people abuse of them because they
are vulnerable and to some extent cannot take care of themselves. It is our
duty to protect those who cannot protect themselves. In order to teach humans
about animal rights we need to take into consideration what these rights are. Animals
deserve rights, and to know which ones should be put in place we can use the
similarity approach, let be approach, and a moral approach. The article
Perpetual Strangers: Animals and the Cosmopolitan Rights by Steve Cook provides
an analysis of the potential ways that we should treat nonhuman animals. This
article, focuses on the use of logos and pathos to state the point that animals
deserve a better treatment and that we are responsible for providing that to
them. “…The similarity approach attempts to demonstrate that non-human animals
are ‘like us’ in some respect by highlighting behaviours and characteristics
that resemble human characteristics, such as the use of language, social
behaviour, moral emotions or familiar-seeming behaviours” (Cooke 933). The
similarity approach in the article Perpetual Strangers: Animals and the
Cosmopolitan Rights, brings up a good point about focusing on the similarities
between humans and animals. This would help us see why we should treat animals
better. “…‘let be’ approach which calls for humans and animals to live separate
lives through the ending of domestication and the protection of wilderness
areas” (Cooke 934). I agree with this approach because it is not fair that we
invade animals living areas to bring them to our zoos but yet we expect animals
to be harmless to us. The best way to make sure that this does not happen
anymore is stop domesticating them and protecting their wild areas. And the use
of a moral approach to animal rights would be beneficial because it is our duty
to protect those in need. It is the right thing to do. Animals are vulnerable
and we tend to take advantage of that, this is why there is a lot of negligence
with animals. This has to change and by implementing the similarity approach,
the let be approach, and a moral approach we can make a difference.
Work Cited
Cooke, Steve.
"Perpetual Strangers: Animals And The Cosmopolitan Right." Political
Studies 62.4 (2014): 930-944. Academic Search Premier.
Web. 10 June 2015.
it the right for animals to stay in the natural living habitat. That is where they belong. It is nice to be able to go to the zoo to see these animals, but some of them are not better off in the wild where they are free to roam and be free. I always feel sad going to the zoo and these animals seem unhappy or drugged up they are walking circles or laying life less. I almost want to open the cage and set them free. and on the hand I don't want to be the one they eat.
ReplyDeleteWhy didn't you help your fellow student by telling him that this is not a human rights issue, and therefore, not part of the assignment?
DeleteYou make a great point, animals deserve to be where they belong, not imprisoned as they probably feel. Most animals are sweet and loving but we take advantage that they can't say no. One of the most frustrating things to see is violence against animals. i think if you added something about animal abuse it would make your stance on pathos more effective because it will make people sad or angry. Those are the two main emotions that make people want to make a change. Other than that your points are credible and your post definitely explains how we take advantage of animals instead of treating them with respect and letting them be happy.
ReplyDeleteAngie Macias
Why didn't you help your fellow student by telling him that this is not a human rights issue, and therefore, not part of the assignment?
DeleteEvery living thing has the right to chose where they belong and what they call home, that is no different to animals or humans. I completely agree on your viewpoint on protecting the wildlife area where the animals live instead of putting them in zoos. Most animals need the natural instinct and way of like to survive in the wild, so what happens when you put them in the zoo for a long time and then decide to release them? They will not be able to fend off for themselves and would most likely struggle to survive.
ReplyDeleteWhy didn't you help your fellow student by telling him that this is not a human rights issue, and therefore, not part of the assignment?
Delete